Skip to main content

Canvas vs. leather shoes: When you should wear each

A guide into canvas vs leather

pile of multi colored shoes
Jakob Owens/Unsplash / Unsplash

No matter your preferred style, there’s no shortage of shoe materials for your next pair. In recent seasons, there’s no doubt that the trendiest styles have come from canvas and leather materials. Even though both are taking over the shoe market, they carry vastly different characteristics that can make or break your look and comfort. Both canvas and leather shoes can easily fit into any style or dress code, canvas shoes evoke a more casual look, while leather is saved for dressier moments.

Regardless of the situation, both shoes offer plenty of styles to make up your wardrobe. However, when choosing your next pair, there are a few factors to consider before deciding between canvas or leather. Choosing the right shoe material for you can help prevent uncomfortable situations with your feet and help complete your desired look. 

Recommended Videos

Pros of canvas shoes

black canvas sneakers on beach
Icee Dc/Unsplash / Unsplash

Canvas is a popular option for casual, everyday footwear. Because of its lightweight properties, it is a highly sought-after material for shoes. Primarily used in sneakers, canvas is known for being a durable option that doesn’t constrain the foot. If made out of certain cotton or synthetic fibers, canvas shoes are more durable than other materials, making them a wise investment for shoes you use often.

If composed of more sustainable materials, canvas shoes also benefit from being a more eco-friendly option. While not as flexible, canvas shoes are a lightweight material that will easily let air flow through your shoes, letting your feet breathe throughout the day. Generally considered a low-cost material, canvas shoes tend to be more affordable, allowing users to collect more. 

Cons of canvas shoes

dirty white converse sneakers
Nqobile Vundla/Unsplash / Unsplash

Canvas shoes have many favorable characteristics, but several factors can make them undesirable. For formal dresses, canvas shoes can appear more casual than sophisticated, making them less versatile in certain situations. While many brands have attempted to reimagine canvas shoes to be less casual, they’re still considered too informal. Besides their casual appearance, canvas shoes also tend to be less supportive.

Because of its lightness and thinness, canvas doesn’t have the most rigid structure to protect the foot from outside factors. For those looking for a low-maintenance shoe, the canvas is also easily susceptible to stains and water damage. Unless made of stronger canvas material, standard shoes are prone to breakage from wear and tear, making it likely you’ll have to replace them sooner. 

Pros of leather shoes

close up on brown leather shoes
Ayrus Hill/Unsplash / Unsplash

On the other hand, leather shoes offer a different set of benefits and look. Typically used for dressier styles leather is usually used for dress styles due to its sleek and luxe appearance. Besides its elevated appearance, leather shoes have numerous benefits that make them a wise investment for dressers. Regarding durability and strength, leather tends to outlive other materials, especially when it comes to genuine leather. Optimal for harsh environments, leather shoes can withstand various terrains and atmospheres.

Leather shoes won’t protect you from all external environments, but they can be a great barrier against the elements. Despite the notion that leather might seem constricting and uncomfortable, leather shoes are known for their ability to mold around the foot with frequent use. They take some breaking in, but over time, your leather shoes should be able to provide a perfect fit. For surface cleaning, leather shoes are easy to rinse and dry off easily. 

Cons of leather shoes

man wearing brown leather shoes
Clem Onojeghuo/Unsplash / Unsplash

Just as with canvas shoes, leather isn’t always ideal for users. Because of its premium characteristics and durability, leather shoes are more expensive than other materials. Even though they make great investments, the initial price of leather shoes tends to be higher than most. While leather is great for removing surface-level stains and dirt, it does require another type of maintenance.

This material must be conditioned and cleaned often to preserve its look, as with most leather goods. Without proper care, leather can break and lose its initial shine. Additionally, leather can prove controversial as it is unsustainable, efforts to create cruelty-free leather with a similar look have increased over time. 

What you should consider

close up on shoes on rack
Hermes Rivera/Unsplash / Unsplash

When it comes to canvas versus leather shoes, the choice is dependent on multiple factors. If you’re keen on a casual, everyday option, canvas can be an easy choice. Even if it might need replacing more often, canvas offers flexibility with more looks daily. For those with a more formal or elevated look, leather shoes can be a wise investment for a long-term shoe that will continue to feel comfortable.

Despite their higher price tag, the investment in leather shoes will pay off with continued usage. Even though leather is seen in dressier shoes, other options like loafers and boots can be found for those looking for leather footwear you can wear daily. No matter the choice, it’s clear that canvas and leather footwear will continue to grow and offer even better options. 

Leslie Leon
Leslie is a Los Angeles-based writer and content creator. She is always researching and finding the latest fashion trends…
How to clean leather shoes and protect them from wear and tear
Clean and maintain leather shoes
man wearing leather boots in rain puddle

With shoes like loafers, dress shoes, and leather sneakers rising, it’s easy to give in to the leather footwear trend. Regardless of whether it’s patent or full-grain leather, this fabric is notorious for its sophisticated and stylish look. No matter the occasion, leather continues to be an easy way to add style to even the most casual looks. The rise of leather sneakers has also allowed many to upgrade their looks with a comfortable and practical shoe. While leather certainly has many benefits, it’s a material that requires some care to maintain its sleek look.

As with most leather goods, proper care allows you to extend the lifespan of your shoes throughout the years. While cleaning leather shoes isn’t drastically different than cleaning other materials, keeping in mind the characteristics of leather will help ensure you take the proper steps. With the occasional maintenance and required cleaning, your leather shoes can easily withstand any trend and secure a spot in your wardrobe for seasons. 
How to clean your leather shoes 

Read more
Why you should swap hiking boots for trail runners on your next adventure
Say goodbye to your hiking boots. Here's a better option
Man running on a trail with mountains in the background

For decades, hiking boots have been the go-to shoe for every kind of trail, but modern hikers are beginning to change that. If you've ever worn heavy leather hiking boots on a trip before, you're probably familiar with the blisters, sweaty feet, and sore legs that often come with the journey. While getting out in nature was always the best part of my week, I swapped my heavy hiking boots for some lightweight trail runners last year, and it was the best decision I ever made. Here's why.
Why you should ditch your hiking boots for trail runners

Trail running shoes are a middle ground between sneakers and hiking boots. They're sturdy, but still lightweight enough to reduce strain on your legs as you hike. Most hiking boots have stiff soles, but trail runners will allow you to navigate uneven terrain easily due to the flexible soles. These are great for long-distance hikes, especially where speed and efficiency matter. I also love the fact that trail runners have quick-drying and water-resistant mesh, which allows sweat to evaporate easily for a more comfortable journey (and less stinky shoes!)

Read more
Keep your feet warm and dry: A guide to men’s winter shoes
Snow boots vs. winter shoes
Man wearing hiking boots in the snow with red laces

Are you as sick of winter as I am? Well, buckle up because winter isn't sick of us yet and is sticking around. As I walked to the corner bodega this morning, the snow was falling, and it was sticking. It is doing its best to make our lives more inconvenient by the day, and to keep my car parked permanently in the same place for fear of black ice. It isn't all bad, the best part of the winter is you get to break out your favorite sweaters and the best coats for a few months. You get a break from the sweltering heat of the summer.

The worst part? The snow piles up, and everything becomes more cumbersome. Driving is harder. Walking to the office is more precarious. Even going to get the mail is a pain in the neck, literally, if you fall on the ice. But if you have the proper footwear, that isn't an issue. I learned a hard lesson long ago: The wrong shoes can be the difference between an uneventful trip to the office and a broken tailbone. Men's winter shoes are a must-have for your closet, and they will help you navigate the months until you need to trade them in for the waterproof needs of the April showers.
What kind of shoes to wear in the winter

Read more
OSZAR »